Thursday, August 12, 2010

The Old Man and the Sea: Death?

At the end of the novel The Old Man and the Sea, the main character Santiago possibly dies, but Hemingway makes it unclear. I believe that it would make more sense for Santiago to die because his main goal in life is essentially accomplished by battling the marlin, and I think it is simply his time to go. However, it says in the story that he stumbles back to his shack after catching the marlin and getting back to shore and “passes out” in his newspaper bed. This would be all fine and dandy to me, but it also says that he dreamt peacefully of the lions on the beach, which he previously dreamt of twice before, and he loved them so dearly. That image makes his “passing out” seems like he went to Heaven and died. I do like Santiago so I hope he did not die in the end, but it is simply logical for him to pass away in this spot of the story. Most sources say that Hemingway means the last scene in a literal way; therefore, they say he does not actually die. As I have suggested previously, the lions on the beach are probably a symbol for Santiago’s youth and his old age and death coming together. This symbol suggests even more heavily that Santiago indeed dies in the end. His thoughts of the lions on the beach provoke his death and him going to a better place ultimately. I have become a bit repetitive in my writing, but it is simply to make a strong point. I do believe that Santiago dies, or for that matter should die, in the end of the novel. There is just too much evidence supporting my thoughts. It is completely understandable for him to die in my mind. He just finished fighting a gigantic fish for three days. That can really take a toll on somebody. This is even more evidence supporting Santiago’s death.

4 comments:

  1. sorry, this is really long, but im writing a litarary analysis paper for my english class on how Santiago dies in the end and i thought this would also help the theory. i think your post is really eyeopening, i wouldn't have thought of it that way.

    Manolin and Santiago both new that Santiago was going to die. There are small hints in Santiago and Manolin’s conversation that indicate this. Manolin is at Santiago’s bedside telling him that everything is going to be alright. “But we will fish together now for I have much to learn.” Santiago replied to say, “We must get a good killing lance and always have it on board.” This conversation clearly resembles the one earlier on in the novel where Manolin is with Santiago in his house and is asking him, “What do you have to eat?” Santiago replied, “a pot of yellow rice with fish.” And Manolin said to himself “they went thought this fiction every day.” Manolin is saying that they would go through the fiction of saying that they have things that they wished they had, rather than facing the hard truth. By trying to avoiding the hard truth of Santiago dying, they go through the fiction of fishing together from then on, right after Santiago gets better. Deep down, Santiago and Manolin both know that Santiago’s wounds will not heal and that they will never fish together again, they both knew that Santiago is going to die.

    ReplyDelete